The Republican Party could very well be heading for a “near-extinction-level event,” according to one prominent New York Times columnist, as the mistake of reelecting President Donald Trump now eerily resembles a political wipeout from 132 years ago.
In one of his latest “Takes” videos on YouTube, liberal Times columnist Jamelle Bouie discussed how the recent midterms could very well be signalling a massive shift among voters in the South, with a significant portion of white voters being willing to vote for Democrats after decades of unflinching support for the GOP. This shift was on display in the electorate that elected Scott Colom to the Senate in Mississippi, the state’s first Democratic senator in decades and its first black senator since the end of the Civil War.
As Bouie explained, the loss of a meaningful chunk of the Southern white vote could very easily turn into an existential calamity for the Republican Party, locking it out of holding real political power for a generation or more. To come back from that, the party would have to “respond to these changes and reconfigure itself to win,” but the road back could be arduous for them.
As proof, Bouie noted the striking similarities between the modern GOP and the Democratic Party of the late 19th Century, when it, like with Trump in 2024, elected Grover Cleveland to non-consecutive terms in the White House, and then promptly suffered one of the worst midterm beatings in history, losing both chambers of Congress for the first time ever and losing a still-unbeaten 110 seats in the House.
In the decades that followed, the party became an afterthought in national politics, failing to win the White House again until Woodrow Wilson in 1912.
“The last party, whose president won two non-consecutive terms, was the Democratic Party. Grover Cleveland won two non-consecutive terms,” Bouie explained. “And at the end of that second term, the Democrats suffered such a massive midterm defeat that it was a near extinction-level event for the party. And it would spend the next 20 years struggling to win national elections. Republicans would dominate this period of the late 19th and early 20th century with William McKinley and Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft. And it would not be until 1912, 20 years after Cleveland was elected a second time, that Democrats would recapture the White House. I’m not saying that’s what’s going to happen to Republicans, but I wouldn’t be too surprised if it did. That’s the kind of tectonic shift we might be party to as a result of these midterm elections.”
