While psychiatrists are discouraged from diagnosing public figures they have not personally met, the same standard does not apply to ordinary citizens and politicians. In that spirit, a veteran journalist observed on Wednesday that Democrats may plan on disempowering the lame-duck president, Donald Trump, by treating him as if he is already a literally inept and incapable old man.
“A top journalist thinks the secret to squaring up against President Donald Trump lies in his age,” reported The Daily Beast’s Julia Ornedo & The Daily Beast Podcast on Wednesday. “Kara Swisher, a veteran tech reporter, says Democrats who rode into Congress on a blue tsunami need to lean into the ‘addled’ 80-year-old president’s senility—instead of going straight after him guns blazing.”
Swisher told The Daily Beast’s Joanna Coles, “To me, going after Trump, as much as it would tickle your receptor, is just not going to work. He gets power from it, right? He gets recharged, and so him playing the victim is his favorite role. Like, ‘Oh, poor me.’ And he’ll get power from it. So why give it to him?”
By contrast, she urged Democrats to follow the approach advocated by one of their potential 2028 presidential candidates, former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel.
“He goes, ‘If we win the election in a big way—just, he’s an old man,'” Swisher observed. “Like, ‘Who, Donald, who?’ Like that kind of thing. So I would treat Donald like that,” she said. “I would treat him like, ‘Who? Did you say something? I’m sorry, I didn’t hear you because you’re mumbling, old man,’ kind of thing.”
Swisher went on, “You know, ‘Is he yelling again? Just give him a cracker, give him a cookie,’ that kind of thing. ‘Have Natalie [Harp] take him out,’ that kind of thing. That’s how I would treat him,” she continued. “I would treat him almost with disrespect. And as much as I don’t want to disrespect the office, I would disrespect the man, essentially, because he deserves it.”
Not all experts believe that it is appropriate to target the president based on his age. S. Jay Olshansky, a University of Illinois Chicago emeritus professor best known for developing the “biodemographic paradigm” of mortality, told AlterNet in September that he is skeptical of people who claim the president’s age is impairing his performance.
“I have no basis for making any assessment at all about cognitive functioning,” Olshansky told AlterNet. “And actually, nor does anyone else, perhaps except his doctors. So, honestly, I don’t trust videos that I see. Those can be doctored and altered. I don’t trust audio that I hear; those can be doctored and altered. I don’t trust opinions of others based on video and audio, because those are often influenced by politics.”
He concluded, “Bottom line is I think very few people have any valid basis for drawing any conclusion about cognitive functioning about the president.”
