[[{“value”:”Coffee is the most popular kid on the block—or rather, the most desired hot beverage in the country. In fact, according to the Spring 2026 National Coffee Data Trends (NCDT) report, almost 195 million American adults enjoy their go-to coffee drink each week, making coffee the most popular beverage in the United States.
One thing that varies among coffee enthusiasts? The fixings. When it comes to coffee creamers, there are decadent options to suit everyone’s tastebuds, from hazelnut, sweet cream, caramel, and French vanilla to banana bread, pumpkin spice, brown sugar, and more. But before you head to the grocery store, there’s some important information you should know.
We spoke with Theresa Link, RD, a Registered Dietitian at Virta Health, and learned six types of coffee creamers you may want to swap out for healthier alternatives.
Before diving in, Link recommends being a mindful label reader the next time you stock up on coffee creamers. Keep an eye out for added sugar content, which is simple to spot on the nutrition label and is typically located near the top of the ingredient list.
“It’s equally important to watch for refined seed oils like soybean, corn, and general vegetable oil. While saturated fat from full-fat dairy sources (like heavy cream or half-and-half) is a healthy option, most commercially available creamers swap high-quality dairy fats for these highly processed seed oils instead,” Link explains.
In addition, be cautious of front-of-package claims. Link notes that heavy advertising of terms such as “natural” could mean a product is highly processed.
“Claims like ‘plant-based’ usually mean non-dairy, which can be misleading because these products often rely heavily on seed oils, and certain milk bases—like oat milk—are naturally high in carbohydrates even without added dairy,” Link adds.
Below, Link shares six types of coffee creamers she recommends limiting, in addition to product examples that fall into each category. Always read ingredient lists and Nutrition Facts labels before adding a product to your cart, and speak with your dietitian or other healthcare professional if you have any questions or concerns.
Powdered Non-Dairy Creamers
Link recommends reviewing the ingredients in powdered non-dairy creamers, as some varieties contain hydrogenated vegetable oils and corn syrup solids
“The corn syrup rapidly spikes blood sugar and insulin levels,” she says.
One example of a powdered non-dairy creamer Link includes in this category is Coffee Mate’s Original Powdered Coffee Creamer. According to the product’s ingredient list, it contains corn syrup solids and hydrogenated vegetable oil.
Liquid Sweetened Flavored Creamers
As far as liquid sweetened flavored creamers are concerned, Link says to be cautious of high-fructose corn syrup and inflammatory oils like palm and soybean oil.
“This combination drives blood sugar and insulin spikes while delivering highly processed fats that negatively impact metabolic health,” she explains.
Two examples of liquid sweetened flavored creamers Link shares for this category are International Delight’s French Vanilla and Peppermint Mocha Coffee Creamer. According to their ingredient list, both contain palm oil.
RELATED: The #1 Unhealthiest Order at 30 Major Fast-Food Chains
Sugary Oat Milk Creamers
Some oat milk creamers contain added sugar, which can increase your calorie intake without providing any nutritional benefit. In addition, consuming too much added sugar regularly could be hazardous to your health. According to the American Heart Association, men should limit added sugar to 9 teaspoons per day, while women should not exceed 6 teaspoons per day.
“Because oats are already high in carbs, combining them with added sugar creates a high-glycemic mix that rapidly spikes blood sugar and insulin,” Link tells us.
Overall, it’s important to be mindful of your daily added sugar intake. Two examples Link includes in the sugary oat milk creamer category are certain Planet Oat and sweetened Oatly creamers. For instance, Planet Oat’s Brown Sugar Cookie Oatmilk Creamer, Coffee Cake Oatmilk Creamer, and Caramel Oatmilk Creamer each contain 4g of added sugar per serving, while Oatly’s Oatmilk Creamer Sweet & Creamy also contains 4g of added sugar in a serving, according to their Nutrition Facts labels.
RELATED: The 60 Unhealthiest Grocery Store Foods in America
Fat-Free Flavored Creamers
Some fat-free flavored creamers contain added sugars and vegetable gums, Link points out.
“When manufacturers strip out the natural fat, they replace it with higher amounts of sugar,” she explains.
One example Link selected for the fat-free flavored creamer category is Coffee Mate’s Fat-Free French Vanilla Liquid Creamer. According to its Nutrition Facts label, this product contains 5g of total sugars, including 5g of added sugars, per serving.
RELATED: 40 Foods Nutritionists Say Are the Healthiest on the Planet for You
Sweet Cream Cold Foams
Let’s be honest: There’s nothing more enjoyable than topping off an iced latte with a delicious sweet cream cold foam. However, Link says some of these creamers are made with a base of milk, heavy cream, and added sugar.
“While they start with natural dairy, the heavy dose of added sugar spikes blood sugar and insulin, essentially canceling out any benefit of the natural dairy fats,” Link adds.
Two examples Link includes in this category are Dunkin’s Extra Extra Cold Foam Creamer (5g total sugars, including 4g added sugars per serving) and Reddi Wip’s Cold Foam Coffee Topper (6g total sugars, including 6g added sugars per serving).
Zero-Sugar or “Keto” Liquid Flavored Creamers
While certain sugar-free or “keto” coffee creamers may seem like a better option to add to your cup of joe, Link says to be mindful of oils like corn and soybean oil.
“Their poor impact on metabolic health is largely driven by these refined seed oils rather than sugar,” she explains.
One example Link selects for the zero-sugar liquid flavored creamer category is Coffee Mate’s Zero Sugar French Vanilla Coffee Creamer, which contains soybean oil, per the product’s ingredients list.
RELATED: The #1 Unhealthiest Fast Food Fried Chicken You Can Order Right Now
What To Shop For
If coffee creamer is a staple in your morning routine, Link provides healthier alternatives to look for that still offer a creamy, flavor-packed sip.
“Stick with full-fat dairy options like plain half-and-half, heavy cream, or whole milk, avoiding fat-free or reduced-fat versions. For non-dairy options, unsweetened almond milk works well, and even unsweetened oat milk—while higher in carbs—is a far better choice than sugary commercial creamers. If you want a touch of sweetness, try adding a few drops of liquid stevia, liquid monk fruit, or allulose syrup,” Link says.
The post 6 Coffee Creamers a Dietitian Says to Limit, From Coffee Mate to Oatly appeared first on Eat This Not That.”}]]