[[{“value”:”Thanksgiving dinner wouldn’t be complete without a slice of pumpkin pie. But if you’re short on time and want to make holiday prep a little easier, a frozen pumpkin pie can be a surprisingly delicious solution. Bakers say there are store-bought options that offer flaky crusts, creamy pumpkin fillings and warm seasonal spices that can rival homemade versions. Whether you’re hosting a crowd or bringing dessert to dinner, according to bakers Eat This, Not That! reached out to, you can’t go wrong with these six choices.
Marie Callender’s Pumpkin Frozen Pie
A familiar name in the frozen dessert aisle, Marie Callender’s Pumpkin Frozen Pie offers a classic take on pumpkin pie that makes it an easy addition to any Thanksgiving spread. “If I skip making my own pumpkin pie, I choose this frozen store-bought pie because its custard base gives it a rich and creamy flavor profile,” says Kristina Lavallee, Founder and CEO of The Cake Girl. “I’ve found that Marie Callender’s has a flavor-packed cinnamon profile with a delicious, flaky, and buttery crust.” She adds, “When comparing this brand with others, I find this one has a balanced taste rather than just tasting like sugar.” And she isn’t the baking expert who loves Marie Callender’s frozen pumpkin pie. Angela (DeMars) Skogen, Owner & Founder, Cooks On Main, says she recommends the brand because it’s “convenient for people who are into classic pumpkin pie flavors and flaky crust, minus the time and effort it takes to make one.”
The Village Pie Maker
For those who pay close attention to ingredients, The Village Pie Maker is worth a look. “What stands out to me is the ingredient list: pumpkin purée, cream, eggs, brown sugar, and butter,” says Odette D’Aniello, Founder and CEO of Dragonfly Cakes. “Cream adds richness to the filling, while brown sugar brings a little depth that works beautifully with pumpkin and warm spices. This is the option I’d look for at Whole Foods, though availability varies by location.”
Sara Lee
Sometimes, the best holiday desserts are the ones that everyone recognizes, and Sara Lee is a familiar grocery-store brand that everyone loves. It’s a go-to for Skogen because it “fits into the traditional menu of the holiday.” She adds,” If you know your guests and you think they’re more of a traditional-pumpkin-taste people rather than have unfamiliar flavors, then this is your best shot for frozen pies.”
Maine Pie Co–Gluten-Free
Accommodating different dietary needs doesn’t mean sacrificing a holiday favorite. Maine Pie Co. offers a gluten-free pumpkin pie that gives guests with gluten sensitivities an opportunity to enjoy a traditional Thanksgiving dessert alongside everyone else. “I appreciate how straightforward the filling is: pumpkin purée, sweetened condensed milk, eggs, and spices,” says D’Aniello. She explains that, “The crust uses real butter with a blend of rice flours, potato starch, and tapioca starch.” She adds, “These are thoughtful ingredients for a gluten-free pie that still follows the traditional pumpkin custard approach, and it’s great because I have so many gluten-sensitive family and team members, so having this option makes something yummy and easy for everyone to enjoy.”
Costco
If you’re feeding a large crowd, or just want leftovers, Costco’s pumpkin pie is an affordable option that doesn’t skimp on quality or flavor. “Ultimately, my favorite pumpkin pie hack is to get a giant pumpkin pie from Costco and let it warm to room temperature,” says D’Aniello. “It’s always delicious, consistent, giant, and easy to serve. A crowd pleaser without taking up precious space in my oven on a busy cooking day!”
Chef Pierre Pumpkin Pies
Chef Pierre offers two options to suit different Thanksgiving needs that Skogen loves. “The pre-baked pie is a great time-saver, freeing up valuable oven space for other holiday dishes while offering the convenience of a ready-to-serve dessert,” she says. “Meanwhile, the unbaked option is ideal for hosts who prefer more control over the final bake and want to give their pie a fresh-from-the-oven, homemade feel.”
The post 6 Best Frozen Pumpkin Pies for Thanksgiving, According to Bakers appeared first on Eat This Not That.”}]]
