You’ve been putting off purchasing a new set of headphones for weeks. When Black Friday finally comes, Amazon displays a big discount next to the item you’ve been looking at.
It seems to be the ideal moment to make a purchase. But what if two weeks earlier, the same headphones were already selling for that amount?
A new investigation suggests that some Amazon (AMZN) shoppers have faced exactly that situation.
Consumer advocacy group Groundwork Collaborative examined 351 Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday products from 2024 and 2025.
It found that some on-sale items were as expensive — or even more expensive — than their lowest price in the preceding 30 days. Citing issues with the study’s methodology, Amazon vehemently contested the results.
The controversy comes as the retailer prepares for its 2026 Black Friday event, running Nov. 19 through Nov. 30.
The issue is straightforward for American families looking to stretch their Christmas budgets: How can you determine whether a Black Friday offer really saves money?
Also read: Amazon’s $75 AI wearable hides a bigger $144-a-year bet
Groundwork’s 19% finding raises uncomfortable question for Amazon
Groundwork published its investigation on Nov. 16, examining discounts Amazon had featured prominently during previous holiday shopping events. The researchers contrasted the lowest prices offered over the previous month with sale prices.
According to Groundwork Collaborative, nearly three in 10 sampled products had already been available for the same price or less.
A few instances stood out.
Twelve days earlier, the Beats Solo 4 headphones had already hit the advertised price of $129.95 from Black Friday in 2025.
Twenty days before the event, a Fitbit Charge 6 fitness tracker advertised for $99.95 on Cyber Monday sold for the same price.
However, the most significant issue was the rising cost of the items. For example, a pair of Hunter rain boots advertised for $126.99 during Black Friday had cost $79.97 just nine days earlier. That is an additional $47.02, or about 59%.
The median sale price for all goods deemed more costly was 19% higher than the lowest price offered the prior month, suggesting that consumers who wait for a significant sale may lose out on better deals.
But rather than looking at Amazon’s upcoming 2026 event, the research examined a few items from prior years.
More Amazon:
Amazon cuts more jobs as CEO touts record margins, retail gains
Amazon’s latest report left stock investors with one big question
Amazon’s $75 AI wearable hides a bigger $144-a-year bet
Amazon disputes the study’s findings
Amazon claimed that the researchers’ pricing comparisons were deceptive.
In an official response, the retailer said Groundwork’s sample represented only a tiny fraction of the millions of deals offered during the events.
Amazon said its own review found that 98% of the products examined were priced at or below their lowest price during the preceding 30 days. Additionally, it said the probe included certain items that weren’t formally designated as discounts and neglected to appropriately account for early Christmas sales.
The difference is important. Even if consumers could previously have bought a particular product for the same amount, it may still be considered affordable at that price.
Products with official deal badges must meet extra price restrictions, according to Amazon. It added that in 2026, it reinforced its price protections.
The research does not prove that Amazon’s entire Black Friday deal is deceptive. However, the dispute shows how difficult it may be for consumers to evaluate discounts based just on advertised percentages.
Amazon’s Black Friday deals have a surprising 19% catch.Kevin Dietsch / Getty Images
Amazon’s 12-day sale gives shoppers more choices
Millions of discounts on electronics, toys, apparel, and home goods will be available during Amazon’s next event.
In its official announcement, Amazon said discounts could reach 60% on selected products. Additionally, it’s offering extra savings for qualified Prime members, as well as daily themed promotions.
Customers can certainly save money. But they should keep in mind that a 60% advertised reduction does not necessarily mean an item costs 60% less than it did last week. Instead of using the most current selling price, the percentage might be computed using a reference price.
Price history provides a more helpful comparison for consumers. According to Amazon, Alexa for Shopping can provide up to 365 days’ worth of past prices.
Customers can also review past pricing through independent monitoring programs such as Keepa and CamelCamelCamel. Another helpful check is comparing the same item across vendors.
Instead of purchasing anything solely because it has a discount label, it’s important to identify genuine discounts.
Amazon’s holiday discounts create a bigger business test
The risks go beyond single transactions.
Amazon relies on customers coming back to its marketplace, particularly during the cutthroat Christmas season. The store may also face pressure to show that its promotions provide significant value.
It’s unlikely that Amazon’s sales or earnings will be significantly impacted by the sale price dispute. Its vast assortment, delivery network, and Prime membership perks remain significant competitive advantages.
However, when families are carefully controlling their spending, customer trust is extremely important.
Even small discrepancies between advertised and actual savings can add up for an American household buying many Christmas presents. A $20 difference across five purchases means $100 that could have remained in the household budget.
Amazon will put its improved price precautions to the test in real life during its upcoming Black Friday event.
The best course of action for customers is to look up an item’s past price before determining its value. The amount of money you save, not the percentage shown next to the price, is what defines a true deal.
Related: Amazon’s $550 tablet breaks its oldest hardware rule
